Amethyst, Princess of Gemworld: A Magical Girl maxiseries created during early '80s?
Tap here to turn on desktop notifications to get the news sent straight to you. By Sam Sommers In yet another chapter of a continuing debate, the State of Oregon announced last week that its public schools must discontinue the use of Native American nicknames and mascots.
The Board of Education gave state schools until to stop using team names such as "Indians," "Chiefs," "Braves," and "Redskins.
Predictably, reaction to the order has been mixed. Supporters of the ban assert that even if the schools that use them harbor no ill-intent, the images themselves are caricatures that perpetuate stereotypes.
Opponents of the ban suggest that these names celebrate, rather than disparage Native American culture.
And fans of the slippery slope argument would ask what, then, of the other sports nicknames that make reference to a particular group of people, whether in terms of region of origin Vikings, Fighting Irish, Celticsreligion Quakers, Saintsor occupation Boilermakers, Engineers?
For many people the debate comes down to one question: And some would suggest that this is a question best posed to Native Americans directly, including the NCAA, which has previously ordered schools to change their nickname unless they can demonstrate approval from the local tribe in question.
What, specifically, are the psychological implications of these nicknames and mascots? A few years ago, researchers at Arizona, Stanford, and Michigan conducted a series of studies to find out. Their first experiment found evidence to support the idea that sports mascots can be a source of pride in Native American communities.
In this study, high school students on an Indian reservation in Arizona who read a brief paragraph about the use of these mascots accompanied by a photo of Chief Wahoo, the smiling logo of the Cleveland Indians subsequently used more positive words when asked to write down their first thoughts that came to mind in describing Native Americans.
This finding indicates that mascot representations are not always regarded as negative -- and that surveys of members of Native American communities may very well indicate explicit support for the nicknames.
But the question remains, what of the psychological effects of these mascots on Native American individuals? On this count, the data are not so kind to the pro-mascot case.
In follow-up studies, the same researchers again presented high school respondents with various passages and images related to Native Americans. After reading about mascots and seeing Chief WahooNative American respondents scored lower on an individual self-esteem questionnaire, as well as a measure of their sense of community worth i.
In fact, scores for self- and community-worth were even lower among students who had seen Chief Wahoo than they were among those who read about the common depiction of Native American communities as suffering from high rates of alcoholism, suicide, and teen pregnancy. Perhaps most problematically, in a final study a variety of Native American mascots were shown to different groups of college student respondents.
Afterward, students were asked to write about what their life would be like in one year. Those Native American students exposed to mascots were significantly less likely to use achievement-related language in anticipating their future than were students in a control condition. That is, having seen and read about mascots, Native Americans became less likely to make achievement-related predictions for themselves regarding good grades, graduating, finding a job, etc.
The data from these studies are consistent with the idea that these mascots are often viewed positively, even by members of Native American communities.
And, of course, there are yet other questions to be asked about the effects of such mascots. For example, to what extent do they attenuate versus exaggerate racial stereotypes held by White people?
In a separate investigation published ina different set of researchers concluded that Native American mascots activated negative, but not positive, stereotypes among Whites. In the end, these data pose a problem for claims that these mascots are honorific and likely to enhance the self-esteem of Native Americans.
Even when that is or has recently become the motivation behind a team name, such good intent is not sufficient to bring about good outcomes. As the authors of the paper described above explain, "American Indian mascots do not have negative consequences because their content or meaning is inherently negative.Turnitin provides instructors with the tools to prevent plagiarism, engage students in the writing process, and provide personalized feedback.
An Examination of Native American Stereotypes and Mascots in the Movies and Sports in America PAGES 3. WORDS View Full Essay. More essays like this: Not sure what I'd do without @Kibin - Alfredo Alvarez, student @ Miami University.
Exactly what I needed. - Jenna Kraig, student @ UCLA. Foundations of Visual Arts and Design – Elective B This subject is designed to extend the skills developed in Elective A. Assessment: 50% coursework and 50% final examination. including changes that have been incorporated with the growth of internet in business – The legal challenge of Indigenous legal issues following recognition of Native Title and Customary Law.
Download-Theses Mercredi 10 juin Social Education, our peer-reviewed, flagship journal, contains a balance of theoretical content and practical teaching ideas.
The award-winning resources include techniques for using materials in the classroom, information on the latest instructional technology, reviews of educational media. For years, many have said that sports teams with Native American mascots — the Cleveland Indians, Chicago Blackhawks and Florida State Seminoles, to name a few — perpetuate stereotypes against.